As India strives to solidify its position as Asia’s manufacturing powerhouse, the country faces an internal debate on whether to invite Chinese investments, a topic that has stirred considerable discussion within the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). In a recent conversation with CNBC, Samir Kapadia, CEO of India Index and managing principal at Vogel Group, highlighted the complexities and potential opportunities associated with Chinese investments in India’s strategic sectors.

The Internal Conflict Over Chinese Investments

India’s ambition to become a global manufacturing leader is evident in its economic strategies and policy decisions. However, the proposal to encourage foreign direct investment (FDI) from China has sparked an "internal battle" within the BJP. Alicia Garcia-Herrero, chief Asia Pacific economist at Natixis, pointed out that while some government officials see the strategic value in inviting Chinese investments, others are wary of the political and social ramifications.

This internal conflict was underscored by recent events. India’s Chief Economic Advisor, V Anantha Nageswaran, suggested in the country’s annual economic survey that promoting Chinese FDI would be more beneficial than merely increasing trade activity between the two nations. However, this idea was swiftly dismissed by Trade Minister Piyush Goyal, who stated that there was "no rethinking at present" on allowing Chinese investments into India.

The Economic Imperative for Chinese Investments

India’s economic ambitions are clear. The country aims to attract $100 billion in FDI annually over the next five years, a significant increase from the $70.95 billion it received in the financial year 2024. Experts agree that to achieve this goal, especially in critical sectors like solar energy and battery manufacturing, Chinese investments are not just desirable but necessary.

Garcia-Herrero emphasized the importance of Chinese investments in India’s green tech sector, particularly solar panels and batteries. Despite India’s efforts to increase its renewable energy output, the country still lags behind global leaders like China and the United States. "India really can’t afford to miss out on Chinese investment for manufacturing," she noted, adding that China’s cost-effective production of green technology makes it an essential partner for India’s renewable energy ambitions.

Samir Kapadia echoed these sentiments, highlighting that India's battery manufacturing industry, crucial for the country's electric vehicle (EV) targets, is underdeveloped and needs external support. "India doesn’t have a developed EV battery ecosystem and requires third-party support, particularly from countries like China, to accelerate efforts to meet strategic targets," Kapadia stated. He further suggested that by relaxing investment curbs, India could achieve its ambitious goals in the EV sector.

The Geopolitical Tightrope

However, the decision to invite Chinese investments is not just an economic one. It is deeply intertwined with geopolitical considerations, especially given the strained relations between India and China. The two countries have been at odds over several issues, most notably the Himalayan border dispute, which escalated into a deadly clash in 2020.

India’s Foreign Affairs Minister, S. Jaishankar, recently remarked that relations with China are "not good [and] not normal right now." This tense geopolitical backdrop complicates India’s economic decisions, as the government must balance the need for Chinese investments with concerns over national security and regional stability.

Harsh V. Pant, vice president for studies and foreign policy at New Delhi’s Observer Research Foundation, highlighted the delicate balance India must strike. "From an economic point of view, you need Chinese investments in certain sectors, and a perfectly logical argument can be made. But the government of India is going to take a holistic approach where national security and geopolitical dimensions are going to come into the calculus."

The Path Forward: Strategic Investments in Key Sectors

Looking ahead, experts agree that if India is to achieve its manufacturing and economic goals, it must strategically invite investments in sectors that are too big to fail. According to Samir Kapadia, the industries that will attract Chinese investors are those that are crucial for India’s long-term growth. "It’ll be the industries that India has to build over the next five years to be a developed economy that can fully capture its potential at scale," he said, suggesting that the semiconductor industry could be another area where Chinese investments might play a pivotal role.

Conclusion: Navigating the Complex Terrain

India’s journey to becoming a global manufacturing leader is fraught with challenges, both economic and geopolitical. While the country’s renewable energy and battery manufacturing sectors desperately need foreign investments, particularly from China, the decision to invite such investments is not straightforward. The BJP must carefully navigate internal and external pressures, balancing economic needs with national security concerns.

As Samir Kapadia and other experts have pointed out, the path forward requires a nuanced approach that considers both the benefits and risks of Chinese investments. If managed wisely, these investments could propel India closer to its goal of becoming Asia’s manufacturing powerhouse, but only if the country can successfully balance its economic ambitions with its geopolitical realities.

To read the entire article and Samir’s insights - Click Here